Average IRR of Mixed-Use Real Estate Deals

 The average Internal Rate of Return (IRR) in mixed real estate can vary widely depending on a variety of factors, including the specific project, location, financing structure, and overall market conditions.

Generally speaking, mixed real estate projects that are well-planned, well-executed, and located in strong markets tend to generate higher IRRs. However, there is no single average IRR that applies to all mixed real estate projects.

In practice, IRRs in mixed real estate can range from low single digits for low-risk, income-producing projects to high double digits or even over 100% for higher-risk, value-add or opportunistic projects.

It's important to note that IRR is just one measure of investment performance and should be considered in conjunction with other metrics such as cash-on-cash returns, equity multiple, and risk-adjusted returns to get a more complete picture of the investment's potential.

What Makes a Mixed-Use Real Estate Deal Risky?

  • Market conditions: The success of a mixed-use development depends heavily on local market conditions, including supply and demand for various types of real estate, economic growth, and demographic trends. If market conditions change unexpectedly, the value of the property and the ability to lease or sell space could be negatively impacted.
  • Location: A less desirable or less accessible location may struggle to attract tenants and generate sufficient rental income, which can lead to lower returns or even losses.
  • Zoning and permitting: Zoning changes and multiple permits, which can be time-consuming and expensive are a risk. Any delays or changes in the permitting process can impact the timeline and budget of the project, which can be costly for investors.
  • Construction and design: Mixed-use developments often require complex design and construction, which can increase the risk of construction delays, cost overruns, and quality control issues. If the project is not completed on time and on budget, it can negatively impact the overall profitability of the project.
  • Tenant mix: The success of a mixed-use development depends on having a good balance of residential, commercial, and retail tenants. If the tenant mix is unbalanced or does not appeal to the target market, it can lead to higher vacancies and lower rental rates.
  • Tenant turnover: Mixed-use developments typically have a variety of tenants, including residential, commercial, and retail, which can make tenant turnover more complex and unpredictable. If a large commercial or retail tenant vacates, it can be challenging to find a replacement tenant and maintain occupancy levels.
  • Financing and capital structure: Mixed-use developments typically require significant upfront investment, which can make financing and capital structure complex. If the financing is not structured properly, it can increase the risk of default and impact the overall profitability of the project.
  • Regulatory risks: Mixed-use developments are often subject to more complex regulatory requirements, such as zoning regulations and building codes. Non-compliance with these regulations can lead to fines, delays, and additional costs.

What Cities Offer the Greatest Return on Investment Opportunities for Real Estate and Why?

The areas of the United States with the highest returns for mixed-use real estate investment can vary depending on a number of factors, including local market conditions, economic growth, population growth, and demographics. Here are a few areas that have historically been considered strong markets for mixed-use real estate investment:
  • New York City, NY: New York City has a highly diverse economy and a large population, which makes it a strong market for mixed-use real estate. The city has a high demand for residential, commercial, and retail space, and it's a popular destination for tourists and business travelers.
  • San Francisco, CA: San Francisco is another strong market for mixed-use real estate investment. The city has a thriving tech industry, a large population, and a high demand for both residential and commercial space.
  • Boston, MA: Boston is home to a number of prestigious universities, which makes it a strong market for student housing and mixed-use development. The city also has a growing biotech industry and a strong economy overall.
  • Austin, TX: Austin has experienced significant population growth in recent years, which has driven demand for both residential and commercial space. The city also has a strong tech industry and a thriving arts and culture scene.
  • Miami, FL: Miami is a popular tourist destination and has a growing population, which makes it a strong market for mixed-use real estate investment. The city has a diverse economy, with a strong focus on finance, healthcare, and tourism.
What Are Some of the Best Performing Types of Mixed-Use Real Estate

  • Mixed-use developments with apartments or condos on top of ground-floor retail space are popular in urban areas with high population density and demand for both housing and retail services. These types of properties often generate high rental rates and occupancy levels for both residential and commercial tenants.
  • Live-work developments that provide a combination of residential and office space are popular among small business owners and entrepreneurs who want to work from home. These types of properties can also generate rental income from commercial tenants, such as restaurants or retail shops.
  • Mixed-use developments that combine hospitality and residential space, such as hotels with luxury apartments, can generate high returns through both short-term and long-term rentals.
  • Mixed-use developments that incorporate entertainment venues, such as theaters or music venues, along with retail and dining options, can attract a wide range of visitors and generate strong returns through ticket sales and tenant rents.
  • Mixed-use developments that incorporate educational or healthcare facilities, such as universities or medical clinics, can provide stable, long-term leases with high occupancy levels.
More Real Estate Underwriting Models / Templates: